EU-Turkey deal to return refugees from Greece comes into force
The deal between the EU and Turkey on returning migrants who cross the Aegean sea to Greece has come into effect. Any refugees arriving in Greece can now expect to be sent back to Turkey if they do not apply for asylum or if their claim is rejected.
The deal between the EU and Turkey, struck on Friday, has been criticised by aid agencies as inhumane. The UN’s refugee agency said big questions remained about how the deal would work in practice and called for urgent improvements to Greece’s system for assessing refugees.
Thousands of refugees who arrived in Greece before the deadline will be resettled in Europe, although they cannot choose where. The German chancellor, Angela Merkel, urged refugees at Idomeni to move to other accommodation being offered by the Greek authorities. Some 14,000 people are waiting at the border village in the hope of travelling north.
“I want to take the opportunity to tell the refugees at Idomeni that they should trust the Greek government and move to other accommodation where the conditions will be significantly better,” Merkel said. She added that “from there, Greece will put asylum procedures in motion or redistribution to other European countries will take place”.
In exchange for taking in refugees, Turkey can expect “re-energised” talks on its EU membership, with the promise of negotiations on one policy area to be opened before July. Although this is a climbdown by Turkey, after Cyprus blocked a more ambitious restart of accession talks, Davutoğlu said it was “a historic day” for EU-Turkey relations.
But the head of the UN high commissioner for human rights in Europe raised concerns that safeguards intended to protect vulnerable asylum seekers would not be in place in time.
Vincent Cochetel, director of the UNHCR for Europe, said the agreement was legal on paper, but questions remained on how it was implemented. “For us the proof is in the pudding. Clearly the deal on paper is consistent with international law and standards. The worry is that the safeguards will not be in place on 20 March.”
People claiming asylum needed access to interpreters and the right of appeal, he said, vital elements of a functioning asylum system that Greece has struggled to put in place until now. Implementation “is a big question mark, it is a big challenge”.
Aid agencies accused the EU of failing to respect the spirit of EU and international laws. “This is a dark day for the refugee convention, a dark day for Europe and a dark day for humanity,” said Kate Allen of Amnesty International. Action Aid’s Mike Noyes claimed the deal would “effectively turn the Greek islands … into prison camps where terrified people are held against their will before being deported back to Turkey”.
Facing criticism that Turkey is not a safe third country, Davutoğlu defended his country’s record in sheltering 2.8 million refugees. Those who criticise Turkey “have to provide us with a better option”, he said.
The controversial one-for-one deal remains intact: for every Syrian refugee that the EU sends back across the Aegean, a Syrian in Turkey will be given a new home in Europe. But a cap of 72,000 places has been put on Syrians who will be given asylum in Europe, far short of the 108,000 a year recommended by international aid agencies, if the EU is to do its fair share. The scheme will be stopped once more than 72,000 people have been settled in Europe, amid concerns among some countries of an “open-ended commitment”.
The deal was agreed despite lacerating criticism from Turkey’s president, who attacked Europe’s “shameful” record on refugees as the summit got underway. Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, who was not taking part in the Brussels talks, said Europe should look at its own record on refugees before telling Turkey what to do.
“At a time when Turkey is hosting 3 million, those who are unable to find space for a handful of refugees, who in the middle of Europe keep these innocents in shameful conditions, must first to look at themselves,” Erdoğan told Turkish television.
Approximately 45,000 people are trapped in Greece, including 14,000 who are living in squalid conditions near the Greek-Macedonian border at Idomeni, as they are barred from travelling onwards to central and northern Europe.
Erdoğan, who last year threatened to send millions of refugees to Europe on buses and planes, has been frozen out by the EU hierarchy for almost a decade over concerns about his record on human rights and press freedom.
In a speech where he criticised the EU for backing Kurdish rebels, Erdoğan also warned that European cities faced repeated terror attacks that have struck Turkey in recent months, some of which have been claimed by Kurdish fighters and others blamed on Islamic State. “Despite this clear reality, European countries are paying no attention, as if dancing on a minefield.”
Davutoğlu, a more emollient figure, was despatched to Brussels to finalise a refugee pact. He secured a promise from the EU to speed up the disbursement of €3bn (£2.3bn) intended to help Syrian refugees in Turkey, with new projects to be agreed this week. Turkey has pledged that all returned people will be treated in line with international law, including guarantees that they will not be returned to the countries they have fled from.
On Turkey’s most prized objective of easing visa restrictions, Davutoğlu was confident this could be done by Ankara’s preferred end of June deadline, although his government has only met half of the EU’s 72 bureaucratic conditions.
Anyone making an asylum claim in Greece would be guaranteed a personal interview and the right of appeal. In theory, this would allow asylum seekers, for example Kurds, to make a case for not being sent back to Turkey.
Athens and EU authorities will have to build a functioning asylum system in Greece within days. About 4,000 extra staff – judges, case officers, border guards and translators – will need to be sent from across the EU to the Greek islands to ensure claims can be processed at an estimated cost of up to €300m. “Greece is faced by a herculean task, it is the largest challenge the EU has yet faced,” said the European commission president Jean-Claude Juncker.
The returns programme will not apply to the 45,000 refugees and migrants now in Greece, who can expect to be relocated to other countries in the EU, if they are deemed to have a valid asylum claim.
EU officials expressed confidence that a target of resettling 6,000 refugees a month around the bloc was possible, despite laggardly progress on existing schemes. “We expect we will be able to reach this number because member states at this meeting and previous meetings have promised to step up their efforts,” Juncker said. But the scale of the task is underscored by slow progress on existing schemes: a plan to relocate 160,000 refugees from Greece and Italy to other EU countries has led to fewer than 1,000 finding new homes.
You may be interested
Pakistani gang leader arrested by Greek policemakis - Nov 27, 2020
The Pakistani leader of a gang, whose knife-wielding members broke into an apartment in Kaminia last Saturday and slaughtered a…
These blood types have a lower risk of contracting Covid-19Panos - Nov 27, 2020
New research adds to the growing body of evidence that people with blood type ‘O’ may have a lower risk…
Former New York Times reporter blasts Amazon for censorship over Covid-19 masksPanos - Nov 27, 2020
Former New York Times reporter Alex Berenson has slammed Amazon for attempted ‘censorship’ after the company backed down from its…